Sibling Rivalry: Why Can’t We All Just Get Along?

Cain and Abel
Paris and Nicky Hilton
Donny and Marie Osmond
Jack and Bobby Kennedy
Venus and Serena Williams
Alec, Daniel, William, and Stephen Baldwin

All are famous, all are well known, and all are siblings. But whether siblings are among the rich and famous, or just part of our own everyday lives, they do influence how we turn out. Ironically research about siblings has largely been ignored in child development. That is until now. (And that’s despite the fact that siblings actually spend more time together than with their parents!)

(Check out the video from the Today show!)

Over the last decade fascinating studies have revealed new insights about sibling relationships that just may be helpful in our parenting. We know that sibling rivalry is indeed normal. (Shouldn’t take rocket science to figure out that one, but at least we can alleviate guilt if our kids aren’t bosom buddies). We also know rivalry can last through adulthood and cloud our childhoods and that our sibs do influence our development. We also now know that those squabbles actually can help our kids learn to handle life better. (Click here for my tips to curb sibling bickering and halt homefront battles.)

Here are nine of the most interesting new research findings about sibling rivalry:

Expect it! Studies show that one third of adults admit to having a rivalrous relationship with their sibs. Those squabbles and jealousies are normal and healthy to a certain extent. Investigations now show that minor sibling tiffs actually help kids learn to handle conflicts and deal with the outside world better.

Deep down be more intentional. Researchers videotaped adolescents interacting with their parents. Though moms and dads adamantly denied having a favorite, their kids still named who was “the most loved sibling.” What’s more, when researchers analyzed the tapes, they could identify the favorite kid as well. Just a word to the wise: Tune in to your behavior. As much as we try to not show favoritism, studies reveal that kids do pick up our preferences. A quick quiz is to honestly ask yourself: “Do my eyes light up with the same intensity when you see each of your kids?” Enough said.

Never compare! Research repeatedly finds that the top reason for sibling rivalry is when parents compare their children. Make this your sacred vow: Avoid comparisons and emphasize each child’s individual strengths instead.

Don’t be too involved in those squabbles. The less involved you are in those sib tiffs the better. Your kids won’t use you as negotiator, rivalry will decrease (since they won’t accuse you of “taking sides”) and your kids will learn to rely on themselves to solve their own squabbles. While it’s absolutely fine to step in when you hear a blood-curdling cry (take it from a mom of three boys -- it cuts down dramatically on emergency room visits so please do) research also shows that kids see our involvement as “showing favoritism.” So step back.

Keep up with the research! If you hear, “Toddlers are too young to be jealous!” don’t believe it. Texas Tech University researchers videotaped moms told to lovingly caress a doll. Their seven-month olds turned absolutely green-eyed! Babies are much more jealousy-prone and emotionally savvy than we ever suspected. Watch your coos (when directed towards another baby, anyway).

Don’t overlook older sibs. Anthropologists discovered that cultures where there is far less sibling jealousy are those in which new babies are taken more in stride. Because our kids are generally raised in smaller households, a newborn becomes a “big deal”, and older sibs are more likely to feel left out. So if you want to reduce “older sibling jealousy,” researchers would tell you to make sure you and your guests don’t overlook your other children.

Stress conflict resolution. Researchers visited the homes of 90 two-year-olds and watched how they got along with siblings. They revisited them as preschoolers and finally observed them at school. Those kids who practiced conflict-resolution skills at home (because their parents taught them how to solve their own problems!!!) carried those abilities into the classroom. So, teach your kids how to get along, so they can get along.

Teach kids problem solving skills. Do teach your kids simple ways to solve their problems. Some of the best are “oldie but goodie” techniques that reduce squabbles such as: rock, paper, scissors; drawing straws, tossing a coin, oven timers (“You can use it until the timer goes off, then it’s my turn”), tossing a dice (“Highest number chooses first”). They are great sanity savers for now, but also teach beginning negotiation skills our kids will need for later.

Bottom line: Most siblings experience some degree of jealousy or competition, but it's the parents who play a major role in making children feel secure. Being a little more understanding, giving genuine praise and instilling confidence in children, can lead to a secure sibling relationship. The next time you’re hearing battle cries from your kids, pat yourself on the back. It’s normal! Now take a few deep breaths, and remind yourself to use the opportunity to teach your kids a few “get-along skills.” And do remember to enjoy the summer!


Michele's latest book is 12 Simple Secrets Real Moms Know: Getting Back to Basics and Raising Happy Kids.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Sibling Rivalry: Why Can’t We All Just Get Along?.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://micheleborba.ivillage.com/system/mt-tb.cgi/2387

7 Comments

Andrea said:

I am fifteen years old and a little more than two years younger than my brother. When we were younger, we sometimes had arguements about the dumbest things. But now we're best friends. We go to the movies together and have so much fun together. I'm not looking forward to him going to college at all! All siblings are going to argue at least some of the time, simply because they're two (or more) different people with different personalities and different opinions. But once they overcome their differences and grow up, they eventually figure out that they can be friends. They'll also find out how extremely lucky they are to have a sibling, because that gives them someone to play with and hang out with all the time.

Anonymous said:

I have grown up with a sibling who was younger, and got all the compliments about how cute she is, and how she was going to be Miss. America particulary by our grandparents.

That turned her into a stuck up and self-centered adult, she is also bossy. This made wish that I was an only child. I recommend parents to treat each child equally, (if you have to have more than one) and make sure grandparents, aunts and uncles do the same (etc). Raise them to have confidence, self-esteem and to be humble with their confidence.

No name said:

Parents please try harder not to show favorites! My brother was more favored by my mom because he was the 1st child and he was most outgoing.I was the girl who was terribly shy and playing favorites was always obvious to me from a very young age. Even today after her death I have those sad memories.

Kelli said:

I Have 6 kids Candi-17 Kodie-14 Kirsti-12 Keely-7 Carly-3 Claire-9m They all fight constantly and I'm always working so my poor 17 year old gets stuk babysitting a lot of weekends....but she's my 1 and only hope and I love all of them!!!!!!

Anonymous said:

i am two years younger than my sister, and we are like night and day. she is very picky, demanding, and rude. i sometimes feel inferior to her because she earns more money than me. but still, she is not very pleasant to be around. it's sad, because she is my only sister and i love her very much. but i wish she was less stuck-up and rude. she is even rude to my parents, and they can't stand it. it seems like none of us can talk to her about anything without her flipping out at us. and she wonders why i don't hang out with her very often, considering we only live a few subway stops away from each other. it's not just because we don't have a lot in common. she just isn't very nice.

kathleen said:

I am 8 years older than my brother and I have adored him since the day he was he was born (in spite of the fact that he had severe ADHD and has had alot of problems as an adult as well) and it's a good thing I did because our single mother left me in charge of him alot. I now have four kids; two sons ages 15 and 12 and two adopted girls ages 7 and 8. The girls have a close, love you - hate you, relationship and the boys get long really well but they don't seem to like the little ones much . they say they are annoying and avoid them as much as possible. The little ones look up to the big ones and occationally try to get their attention (usually by doing something annoying) but the big kids just tell them to go away. I donn't understand this because I got so much out of loving my little brother and we are still close. It makes me sad sometimes.

Abel said:

Teaching children to be independent and problem solving skills are utmost important. Parents must not overprotect. Great article.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Michele Borba

About Me

Author of books like No More Misbehavin' and Don't Give Me That Attitude!, parenting expert, educational psychologist, Today show contributor and mom Michele Borba is here to help you.

RSS

Favorite Posts

Archives

Favorite Links